We received a surprise delivery from my sister and her husband, earlier today!
And what a great (lockdown) surprise it turned out to be. We’ve already polished off a few of the pies and they were AMAZING.
I immediately jumped on the web and ordered some for friends and was surprised again by how cheap they were.
Thank you so so much for the wonderful service you and your team provided on our wedding day. It was perfect. The pies were delicious… I honesty can’t thank you enough. The day ran so smoothly and you guys were brilliant.
Loads of our guests have commented about how lovely the pies were and how amazing the staff were! Thank you.
Amazing pies by a brilliant chap! Thoroughly recommend wedding catering by Jack!
Amazing Wedding Food
Pie Eyed did our wedding catering earlier this month. Jack and the team were amazing. Everything was really well organised and the food was excellent. They supplied canapes, a selection of pies and chocolate brownies for desert and then fish finger sandwiches later on in the evening. All the guests commented on how great the food was and no-one went home hungry. Would definitely recommend!
These pies are outstanding. Pie Eyed catered at our wedding. Every guest enjoyed their meal. Both vegetarian and meat pies were beautiful. Highly recommend!
Pie Eyed catered our wedding this weekend and did an absolutely stand-out job. The pies were amazing as usual, but don’t let the name fool you – they also did us a sticky toffee pudding which was one of the best I’ve ever had (and I say that as a sticky toffee pudding connoisseur). The food was mentioned on every other page in our guest book so was clearly a hit! I also had to unzip my wedding dress during the meal then be stitched back into it afterwards, so be assured that the portion sizes are fit for a northerner. Nothing was too much trouble for Jack and his team, and their friendly and smiley service really added to the atmosphere of the day. Thank you so much!! Amy & CJ x
Jack did the best job ever providing amazing pies to 200 guests at our wedding! It was the perfect wedding food and everyone loved it. Thanks so much
Amazing pies very tasty and fantastic quality and great customer service. I’m hooked and have to have my Pie, Mash and Peas every Thursday from the pop up at Union St.
Thanks for the delicious pies yesterday at Mamas & Papas conference. The steak was so tender it melted in my mouth. Could eat one now!
Amazing Pies & Great service
Pie eyed catered our wedding & it was brilliant. From the sausage rolls & pork scratching bar nibbles to the pie, mash, gravy & mushy peas!! All guests commented on how tasty it was & pie eyed were brilliant at accommodating all of our requests pre wedding!! Could not recommend more highly. Eat their pies now!
Absolutely Perfect Wedding Pies
We used Pie Eyed as our wedding caterers in September 2019, and it honestly couldn’t have been any better! The selection of flavours were fab, everyone was so impressed and they tasted amazing. All 80 pies were served hot and exactly on time, and our guests said it was the best wedding meal they had ever had. Perfect for lining those stomachs before the reception! Massive thanks to Jack, Philipa and the team for everything!!
We got married in May and Jack catered our wedding for us – and it was absolutely spot on. From the moment Jack messaged us we really wanted him and his pies at the wedding, and we couldn’t have asked for more! Everyone commented on how delicious the pies were – will definitely recommend to everyone we can!! Thanks Jack (and your mum!!
Fantastic wedding pies!
It’s taken me a while to get round to writing this, but 3 months later and people are still waxing lyrical about the heavenly pies at our wedding. We had the pie, mash and peas option, with both beef and chicken pies on offer, and it was gorgeous. Everyone queued up and got their own, which kept things very informal.There were veggie, vegan and gluten free diets to cater for – no problem. Pie Eyed also provided our tea and coffee (‘Festival’ /help yourself style) and evening food – fish finger butties were a big hit.
Pie eyed were super organised and professional, easy to get in touch with, flexible, helpful, approachable . No question was too random! On the day, they arrived and set up while we were all offsite doing the actual marrying bit. It was fab to come back to the sight of their cool little horsebox and the smell of pies! They were great to have around, and everything went swimmingly. Our timetable went a bit haywire but that didn’t seem to matter…. Particular praise for the gluten-free option – my friend was overjoyed to be eating the same/as good as everyone else.
Absolutely perfect. Thank you. X
(Excellent seeing you serving the evening food while wearing the Silent Noize headphones… wish I was back there now! )
A huge thanks to Pie Eyed for catering at our wedding, the food was incredible and a week on we are still getting messages from guests about how amazing the pies tasted and how friendly the staff were. Everything from our initial meeting to setting up the day before was incredibly easy- exactly what’s needed during what can be a stressful time. The bar we hired had worked with Pie Eyed before and they too commented and how nice it is to work alongside them. Will most definitely be visiting Sheffield for seconds! Thanks so much for everything! Amel & Pete :-) X
P.s amazing cheesecake too!
HUGE HUGE Wedding Thanks
I just wanted to get in touch to say a massive thank you for providing the most excellent pies and service at our wedding on Saturday.
Your team were professional, friendly, on the ball and just generally blended in with the evening. Amanda who runs Natural Retreats said that she was really impressed and she’s done a lot of weddings there. She said she has taken the details for Pie Eyed and will be recommending you to others that want their wedding there. We will also be recommending you to friends and family also. We have quite a large circle of friends from Sheffield!
So many of our guests came up to us afterwards and asked about the pies and did nothing but complement everything you provided, so thank you very much.
Bethan and Victoria ?
Thank you so much for
Thank you so much for providing amazing pies on our day! All of our guests (and us of course) absolutely loved them.
Jack and his team catered
Jack and his team catered our wedding in Sept and he was an absolute dream from start to finish!
I actually contacted Jack before even sorting a venue because, you know, PIE and he couldn’t have been more amenable, professional and just an all round gent.
It can be daunting organising a wedding where you source individual suppliers for each separate thing, but Jack makes it easy and I had utter confidence that it would be a breeze on the day.
Jack provided us with a nibbly starter platter (not just a pie-man folks!) and then the pies…. oh the pies! Fantastic fillings to choose from, perfect pastry, plentiful and an excellent price. I cannot recommend these guys enough.
We had so many comments both on the day, and afterwards and all were gushing about the pies.
THANK YOU LOVELY!
Delicious. The best pie I ever did eat!
I had the pleasure of working with Pie Eyed at a wedding I was coordinating at Chilli Barn this month. They overcame obstacles such as a broken down vehicle and a muddy field to provide pies to all the wedding guests! They were kind enough to provide event myself with a pie (I love a caterer who feed the staff!!) which was DELICIOUS!! I recommend them to literally everyone looking for an efficient, friendly, tasty catering trailer. Really hope we get to work together again soon And maybe i’ll sneak a different pie to try
The BEST treat in lockdown!
What’s the only thing that can make this seemingly interminable lockdown situation? PIE! We’ve had three deliveries from Jack & Co. since this started and they are an absolute TREAT to brighten up our week. Super tasty, my girlfriend is a massive fan of both the veggie cauli cheese and vegan shepherd’s pie, and they’re so easy to cook at home.
We look forward to them so much – thanks so much for setting up this delivery, guys. A brilliant way to support a crackin’ local business,
You guys are the best, and we recommend you to all our friends!
Two pie lovers wedding dreams come true!
Pie Eyed catered our wedding June and were amazing from start to finish! We were very conscious of the suppliers we had involved as we obviously wanted their product to be fab but we wanted people who felt good to work with to make sure the planning was as stress-free as possible.
Philippa and Jack were amazing, nothing was too much trouble! We had a great time tasting the pies and narrowing it down to the ones our guests would choose from, they went out of their way to make the whole process enjoyable.
We went for pie, peas, mash served at tables and then evening food, all of which was delicious! The staff on the day were so lovely and went above and beyond to make sure the food at our DIY wedding was perfect – they worked so well with all our other food elements and other suppliers which just took so much stress away from us.
So many of our guests said how well fed they were and how great the pies were – even a couple writing in our guestbook that it was their favourite part of the day, even the night time cheese toasties got a mention!
I would 100% recommend these folks! Thanks so so much Pie Eyed!!
Just had my pie and it was lovely. Thank you very much Jacquie and Denise who are behind Wath town hall today (30.04.16).
“We just wanted to say a massive thank you for Saturday. The food was incredible, and everyone has commented on how amazing it was (to the point where I felt really smug that our food beat every other wedding we\u2019ve ever been to). You guys were awesome and really added to the wedding \u2026 We were also really touched by the little gift \u2013 it\u2019s currently sat pride of place in our living room!”
Had pies and dessert at a friend’s wedding. Every aspect was great.
Delicious food for everyone, pies and gravy fit for a northerner, friendly service all day. Thank you!
Just to let you know
Just to let you know the pies went down fantastic on Saturday night. Everyone was asking me where I got them from, some people thought I’d made them, which I had to deny.
We will be back for the next party.
Tried the beef pie at the Peddler’s Night Market and absolutely loved it. Can’t get the pie out of my mind! Hope it’s back again at the next market so I can buy at least a few
Jack provided the catering for our wedding reception and oh.my.word. These pies!
I’d actually hunted Jack down… A couple of bonfire nights ago, I’d tasted the most delicious pies I’d ever got my chops around. When it came to planning wedding, we just knew it had to be Pie Eyed.
He was great right from the word go, keeping in touch with any questions we had and he also popped along to the venue to check it out and to give us free pies
All of our guests have raved about our evening food. The next day, instead of recieving photos of the venue/guests/us…we were actually recieving pictures of empty plates after the guests had taken the leftover pies home and demolished them right to the last crumb!!
Pure pie heaven.
Fantastic Service, food was amazing
We would like to thank Jack and his team for the amazing food and service at our wedding, we had the full monty followed by sticky toffee pudding, we hardly knew Jack and his team was there, they were so professional.
The fish finger/bacon sandwiches/cheese toasties went down a treat in the evening, served from the horse box.
Would highly recommend, they fitted in with our relaxed chilled tipi wedding.
Thanks again guys!
Two types of pastry on one pie – genius. So so delicious!!
The pies are fantastic here! They’re so good, Jack and the team are going to be catering for our wedding in October. Great friendly service!
Brilliant Autumn Wedding
Pie Eyed were FANTASTIC from beginning to end. We found Jack and his team to be friendly, professional and flexible. We received wonderful feedback from all of our guests, remarking how tasty their pies were and also, the lovely sharing boards. We got married in a village hall with Pie Eyed providing table service. The staff they brought with them on the day were great and the food was served promptly and most importantly, it was warm!
We couldn’t recommend Pie Eyed enough and we will certainly be making anniversary trips up to Sheffield to enjoy their brilliant pies.
Thank you so much!
Jennifer & Joshua x
From myself and Karl, we just wanted to send you all a huge thank you for your amazing food and service at our wedding on Saturday. The pies went down an absolute treat (I’m sure you may have noticed some reoccurring guests!!). And we’ve enjoyed the last couple ourselves this evening! It was just lovely to have such happy faces there too, it mades a real difference.
We look forward to eating your pies again soon as part of our American food detox!
Hope you had a good rest and have enjoyed the sun over the last few days.
Sarah & Karl